It’s been a long time now. The first time we can recall writing prose about how Gordon Brown’s predictions for the UK economy were looking optimistic was roughly about the same time we started publishing this newsletter - getting on for three years ago.
Over and over again, economic think tanks, analysts and the media have warned that Gordon has get his sums wrong, and time and time again, Mr Brown has replied by saying he knows something we don’t know.
Then last week he finally bowed to the inevitable. The UK economy, said our Gordon, is to grow at around 2.5% this year. Maybe as slow as 2%, and well short of the original estimates of 3 to 3.5%. But oil is carrying the can. Our chancellor made it clear that the high price of oil is the culprit for the slowdown, and that is clearly not his fault.
“Don’t you believe it” say Gordon’s detractors.
Howard Archer, an economist at Global Insight was quoted in the Business paper as saying: “The strength of oil prices can provide the chancellor with some excuse for missing his growth target, but in reality the causes are much deeper than that.”
Roger Bootle, the head of Capital Economics, which has long been predicting a massive short fall in UK growth compared to official targets, used his regular column in the Sunday Telegraph to say: “Brown, the always right chancellor has been finally forced to admit that he was wrong.”
Two pillars have supported the UK over the last few years. First of all there was that column known as consumer spending. When our euro partners, and even the US, slowed, or even went into recession, the British consumer, whose confidence was fired up by rising house prices, went out and spent.
Then, as debt hit all time highs, and fears over a possible property bubble in the making led to a sharp slowdown in consumer activity, in stepped the government. It spent where our consumers had stopped.
But these two pillars were built on shaky foundations. Neither could last forever, and the prayer was that as they eased, other parts of the UK economy would come to our rescue.
But the high level of consumer and then government spending, meant that the Bank of England was unable to lower the rate of interest like its brethren at the ECB and Fed. As a result manufacturing was hit on two fronts. Despite a massive balance of payments deficit, the pound stayed high, making it harder to allow our manufacturers to compete. And the higher rate of interest made it more costly for them to borrow.
But now, with the UK dipping, some are talking about things getting a lot worse. Yesterday, the Centre of Economics and Business Research warned that slowing growth means taxes will have to rise to fund a growing shortfall in public finances. CEBR chief executive, Douglas McWilliams, said: “He (Gordon Brown) has only two choices - cut spending growth or raise taxes. If the latter, watch out for a mixture of stealth taxes that will be the equivalent of three pence on income tax.”
Of course, there are certain newspapers we know who will spare no words in describing Mr Brown’s shortcomings. Take the lead article in the Business, for example. It said: “From now on, commentators and voters will start to realise - as this newspapers long has - that Emperor Brown is running out of clothes and begin to blame him (rather than the usual ministerial fall guys) for his many failings, from the utter shambles that is tax credits to failing public sector pensions, to rising unemployment, the strangling of business by red tape, to Britain’s growing welfare dependency culture, to an income- tax guidebook which has doubled during the Brown years because of his passion for complexity and tinkering.”
It is worth bearing in mind, however, that despite all the Brown bating, the economic slow down he has foreseen is exactly in line with the prediction by the Item Club, reported here on 19 September, that oil, at its current price, would slow the UK economy down to 2% this year. So in other words, oil is no scapegoat. It is in fact a bona fide reason.
Bookmark this article:
These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.