“Allow me to admit something,” said French President Nicolas Sarkozy in China yesterday.” It was not a big effort for me to accept your invitation. Because if you hadn’t invited me, I would have come anyway.”
What a difference a couple of hundred years can make. When Britain sent a trade mission to China in 1792, under the reign of George III, the UK was running an escalating trade deficit with China. Sound familiar? Britain wanted China’s silk, but all China seemed to want from Britain was its silver. Remember, this was an age when the Industrial Revolution was in top gear, Britain’s industry led the world, and yet all the Chinese Emperor would say was: “We have never valued ingenious articles, not do we have the slightest need of your country’s manufacturers.” Britain eventually solved the problem of China in what amounted to one of the most shameful sagas of Britain’s imperialist era. It did find a product China wanted; opium, and when the Chinese government tried to stop its import, war ensued, which Britain won, Hong Kong was handed over to Britain, and China was forced to accept the import of an addictive substance.
Forward wind the clock a couple of hundred years, and things are similar. The world’s most advanced industrial nation is running up a massive trade deficit with China, and in return China is content to obtain the modern day equivalent of Georgian silver, the US dollar.
And in the US, anti-Chinese paranoia is hitting frightening heights. The call for China to appreciate the yuan is reaching deafening proportions, and that, despite the fact that the economic arguments are far from clear cut. China is still a poor country. A recent report from the Asia Development Bank found there are still 300 million Chinese living on less than a dollar a day, and as a general rule of thumb, economists seem to think that countries suffering from abject poverty need a weaker, not stronger, currency. Besides, if China does let the yuan appreciate significantly, it seems Uncle Sam could be the biggest loser, as the end result will be higher inflation in the US caused by more expensive Chinese imports, meaning that interest rates at a time of severe economic crisis will have to rise.
Of late, the yuan has been appreciating against the dollar a little. So far this year it’s up around 5 per cent against the greenback but, as you know, the dollar has fallen massively against the euro.
There were 1.27 euros to the dollar on the first day of this year, while this morning there are 1.48 euros to the dollar. And so the net effect of a falling dollar while the Chinese currency remains more or less pegged to the US currency, is that the European currency has fallen by around 7 per cent against the yuan this year.
And Mr Sarkozy doesn’t like it. “We need to arrive at currency rates that are harmonious and fair,” he said yesterday at a joint press conference with China’s President Hu Jintao.
Now, Mr Sarkozy seems to have the knack of being able to get away with saying things like that. On his recent trip to the US he drew fine praise indeed from George W, and yet on the same trip warned of a danger of “economic war” with the US. Then again, while he was busy issuing warnings to the US, he also flattered the land of the free. “I get the distinct sense that it is France that has been welcomed so warmly, with so much friendship, so much love. When I say that the French people love the American people, that is the truth and nothing but the truth.”
And that seems to be a part of Mr Sarkozy’s strength. He can say things which, if they had come from anyone else, would have raised hackles, but he charms his way through. He warns of war, but says he loves you. In the presence of the Chinese president he calls for an appreciation of the yuan, and yet projects a degree of enthusiasm for China that other western leaders just can’t match.
And, or so it would appear, La Belle France is the winner, because this weekend he scored two major coups for French business interests in China.
First off, he has agreed an $11.9 billion deal for French state-owned nuclear power company, Areva, to supply two third-generation nuclear reactors to China.
Meanwhile, French utility Electricité de France is to take a 30 per cent stake in a Chinese company that operates the nuclear plants.
Okay, France is not alone is selling expertise on nuclear power to China. Westinghouse Electric Co, which is based in the US, but owned by Japan’s Toshiba, had previously agreed a slightly smaller deal.
But the potential size of this market is huge: easily big enough for both Areva and Westinghouse, and it would appear that both company’s are sitting pretty.
France does, of course, come under heavy criticism for its subsidies to industry. We are not immune to dishing out the criticism, too, often describing Sarkozy as the man carrying out Thatcherite reforms Harold Wilson would have been proud of. But it does appear that the policy of investing billions into the French nuclear power industry, subsidising it to a degree that would have been considered totally unacceptable in the UK, is now paying off.
While doubts still remain over the safety of nuclear power, it has been speculated that the next stage in the industry’s development – the fourth generation of nuclear power plants, are 100 per cent safe, and will be of zero interest to terrorists. And so, France stands as a world leader in what could become one of the most important means of generating energy over the course of this century.
And to really benefit France, half the money China is forking out for the nuclear reactors will be in the form of euros. Normally these deals are settled in dollars. One can speculate on the implications of this. Does it mean China is planning to move further away from the greenback? Does it mean China is listening to calls to allow the yuan to appreciate against the euro? Or does it just mean Sarkozy has oodles of charm?
All in all, then, a pretty successful trip so far for the French premier, but there is more.
For Nick also sold 160 Airbus planes in a deal worth more than $17 billion. Now just a few days ago, Airbus was giving dire warnings about how it was going to suffer from the falling dollar.
As Mr Sarkozy said, “if you hadn’t invited me, I would have come anyway.” You can see why.