Investors who invest in ethical funds have seen negative performance over the last year, but 10 of them managed to outperform the average mainstream unit trust performance.
The last 12 months have been difficult for all fund managers, but particularly so for those running ethical money, due to the constraints as to where they can invest. Clearly, funds which are mandated to avoid oil and commodity-related companies have suffered particularly badly due to the boom in these sectors. Even the top performing ethical fund registered a negative return.
But ethical funds nowadays span various asset classes, including the bond, global equities and UK All Company sectors, so they can be benchmarked both against other ethical funds and against the sector in which they invest.
For instance, the top performing ethical fund over the 12 months to July 2008 was the Royal London Ethical bond fund, which returned -4.4 per cent, outperforming other ethical funds, but not the average performance for the UK bond sector which returned -2.8 per cent.
Elsewhere, the Aberdeen Ethical World fund returned -9.9 per cent over the last year - not a great return you might think - but it was actually better than the average global growth fund which made only -14.2 per cent.
And the F&C Ethical 2 Income Fund also beat the average UK All company sector average of - 19.6 per cent, with a return of -17.5 per cent.
In fact, over the last 12 months, 10 ethical funds have beaten the average mainstream unit trust performance of -13.6 per cent.
But pity the poor ethical fund manager. With the downturn in the world economy, ethical funds managers will continue to face challening investment conditions as ‘booze, bombs and ‘baccy’ stocks, which traditionally perform well during recessions, will be off limits.
Source for all data: Money Management magazine, August 2008 issue.
Returns are for one year to 23rd July 2008, bid to bid basis, income reinvested.
For more on ethical investment visit: www.eiris.org.uk
For more on unit trusts, vist the Defaqto Best Buy tables (click on the sector links on the left hand side):
http://www.defaqto.com/consumer/investments/unit-trust-sectors.aspx
Read our guide to ethical investment:
http://www.defaqto.com/consumer/investments/ethical-investments.aspx




